An Overview of Numeristics and Equipoint Analysis

$$ \def\ds{\displaystyle} \def\fullset{\,\mathord{\lower0.1ex\hbox{$\not$}\mkern-6mu\mathrel\infty}} \def\s#1{\mskip-#1mu} \def\ol#1{\overline{#1}} \def\8{\infty} \def\concat{\mathord{\parallel}} \def\rmopn#1{\mathop{\rm #1}\nolimits} \def\Im{\rmopn{Im}} \def\Re{\rmopn{Re}} \def\sgn{\rmopn{sgn}} $$

Questions and answers

Numeristics brings together some little used mathematical ideas into a unified framework, and it aims to use these ideas in a consistent, useful, elegant, and empowering way. It also enables us to give affirmative answers to the following questions which arise at various levels.

Is there a way to divide by zero? (grade school arithemetic)

 Yes, a nonzero number divided by zero is one or more infinite numbers. This book describes several ways of doing this and emphasizes the method that gives a single infinite number. At the grade school level, this is best expressed in the projectively extended rational numbers, where $\ds\frac10 = \8$.

 Zero divided by zero is an indeterminate expression, whose value is the full class, in symbols $\ds\frac00 = \fullset$.

Can a repeating decimal go out to the left as well as to the right? (junior high arithmetic)

 Yes, for example $\ol3$ has two values, $\8$ and $\ds-\frac13$. See Infinite left decimals in [CR].

Do parallel lines ever meet? (high school geometry)

 Yes, they meet at a point at infinity. See Real infinite element extensions in [CN].

Is there a way to assign a value to $\tan \dfrac\pi2$? (high school trigonometry)

 Yes, $\tan \dfrac\pi2 = \8$. See Real infinite element extensions in [CE], especially Figure 2 below.

Is it possible to do calculus with true infinitesimals and infinite numbers? (undergraduate calculus)

 Yes, this is the subject of the second part of this book, Equipoint analysis [CE]. For example, see Equipoint definitions of derivative and integral.

Can we ever give a meaningful value to divergent series such as $1 + 2 + 4 + \dots$? (undergraduate analysis)

 In all cases, yes. This is the subject of the third part of this book, Divergent series [CD]. This particular series has two values, $\8$ and $-1$. See Some results of equation 2 and Sum of non-idempotents.

Is there a more natural alternative to set theory? (undergraduate or graduate set theory)

 Yes, this is the subject of the first part of this book, Numeristics [CN]. See especially Why numeristics.

Is there an easier way of computing functional derivatives? (undergraduate or graduate calculus of variations)

 Yes, the equipoint calculus of variations. See Functional derivatives in [CE].

Numeristics

The first of the source documents on numeristics is Numeristics: A number-based foundational theory of mathematics [CN]. This document contains basic principles and concepts of numeristics. Key principles and results include the following.

Numeristics bases mathmatics purely on number. Numeristics starts with three numeric ultraprimitives or alternate ways of expressing the ultimate value of mathematics:

Infinity Number, as with everything else, ultimately starts from the infinite. The infinite is inexhaustible and therefore only partly conceptualizable.
Unity Unity, the number $1$, is the first mathematical manifestation. It expresses the unified nature of infinity.
Zero The number $0$ represents the unmanifest quality of pure consciousness. Zero is called the absolute number, because it is the unmanifest state from which all manifestation begins.

In its multiple step phase, numeristics starts with the following primitives, which function somewhat as axioms. These primitives are generally those which exist in “classical mathematics,” by which we mean mathematics as it historically existed before the development of set theory, and which is currently taught at the primary, secondary, and upper division undergraduate levels and include:

  • Natural, integral, rational, real, and complex numbers
  • Addition, multiplication, exponentiation of these numbers and their inverses
  • Usual commutative, associative, and distributive properties of these numbers
  • Elementary equality and order relations
  • Euclidan geometry
  • Ordinary classical logic with quantifiers (first order logic)

Numeristics does not use sets. Numeristics does use a numeristic class is a potentially multivalued number or number-like construction. Numeristic classes have a flat structure: Every number is a single valued class; a class containing a single number is identical to the number: $a = \{a\}$. A class containing multiple numbers distributes operations on it and statements about it over each constituent number: $\{2, 3\} + 1 = \{3, 4\}$.

The empty class or null class, denoted $\emptyset$ or $\{\}$, is a class with no values. For example, $1 \cap 2 = \{\}$.

One important consequence of the flat structure of numeristic classes is that the inverse of a function is always itself a function. For instance, the inverse of $f(x) = x^2$ is $f^{-1}(x) = \pm\sqrt x$. The inverse of a conventionally indeterminate form such as $\ds \frac00$ is the full class, the class of all numeric values. An inverse that has no values for a given point is well defined as the empty class at that point.

O S L C ϕ r 1
Fig. 1:
Projectively extended
real numbers,
$r = \tan\phi$
O C π/2 1
Fig. 2:
Geometric relation
of $0$ and $\8$ in
projectively extended
real numbers

Numeristics uses several methods of adding infinite elements to the real numbers, the primary one being the projectively extended real numbers (which is known to conventional mathematics). The projectively extended real numbers add one infinite element, $\8$, to the real numbers. Thus $\ds \frac10 = \frac20 = \8 = -\8$.

Figures 1 and 2 show how a real number $r$ at position $L$ uniquely maps to some point $S$ on the circle, and the infinite element $\8$ maps to the point $C$ at the top of the circle.

All numeric operations are thus well defined. This includes infinite sums, which are not defined as limits but as sums with an actual infinite number of terms.

Equipoint analysis

The second of the source documents on numeristics is Equipoint analysis: A numeristic approach to calculus [CE]. Equipoint analysis is a system of calculus and analysis using numeristic principles and an extended number system. Key concepts and results include the following.

Each real or complex number is unfolded to a space of infinitely many unfolded numbers within the original, folded real or complex number.

A single value at folded level becomes a multivalued class at the unfolded level. The unfolded members of 0 are a class of infinitesimals. The reciprocals of infinitesimals, which are the unfolded members of $\8$, are a class of infinite numbers.

−2 −1 0 1 2 −2⋅0′ −0′ 0⋅0′ 0′ 2⋅0′
Fig. 3:
Real number line with
microscope view of unfolded $0$

Figure 3 is a diagram of the infinitesimals, through an infinitely magnifying microscope view.

We pick one infinitesimal which is not at the origin of the unfolded class and denote it $0'$. In the unfolding of $\8$, we similarly pick one unfolded infinite and denote it $\8'$.

x f(x) 0 (x,f(x)) x + 0′ f(x + 0′)
Fig. 4:
Calculation of derivative
as slope within a point

The extension of unfolded numbers allows direct arithmetic with infinitesimals and infinite numbers. Figure 4 shows how we use this to define the derivative as an actual ratio of infinitesimals: $$ \frac{df(x)}{dx} \equiv \frac{f(x + 0') - f(x)}{0'}. $$

Using this definition, the derivative of $x^2$ is calculated as follows: $$\eqalign{ f(x) &= x^2 \cr \frac{df(x)}{dx} &\equiv \frac{(x + 0')^2 - x^2}{0'} \cr &= \frac{x^2 + 2\cdot0'x + 0'^2 - x^2}{0'} \cr &= \frac{2\cdot0'x}{0'} \cr &= 2x + 0' \cr &=' 2x, }$$ where $a =' b$ means that the two numbers belong to the same folded number.

x f(x) x − 0′ (x,0′) x + 0′ f(x)
Fig. 5:
Calculation of integral
as sum of zero width rectangles

Similarly, as shown in Figure 5, an integral is defined as an actual sum of an infinite number of infinitesimals: $$ \int_a^b f(x) dx \equiv \sum_{k=1}^{\8'} f \left( a + \frac{k(b-a)}{\8'} \right) \frac{b-a}{\8'}. $$

The integral of $x^2$ is calculated as follows: $$\eqalign{ \int_0^u 2x dx &\equiv \sum_{k=1}^{\8'} 2 \frac{ku}{\8'} \frac{u}{\8'} \cr &= \frac{2u^2}{\8'^2} \sum_{k=1}^{\8'} k \cr &= \frac{2u^2}{\8'^2} \8' \frac{\8' + 1}2 \cr &= u^2 \left( 1 + \frac1{\8'} \right) \cr &= u^2 (1 + 0') \cr &=' u^2. }$$

The direct arithmetic of unfolded numbers allows us to formulate simpler proofs. For example, the proof of the first fundamental theorem of calculus does not require the mean value theorem: $$\eqalign{ \int_a^b \frac{d f(x)}{dx} dx &\equiv \int_a^b \frac{f \left( x - \frac{b-a}{\8'} \right) - f(x)}{\frac{b-a}{\8'}} dx \cr &= \frac{b-a}{\8'} \frac\8'{b-a} \sum_{k=1}^{\8'} f \left( a + \frac{k(b-a)}{\8'} + \frac{b-a}{\8'} \right) - f \left( a + \frac{k(b-a)}{\8'} \right) \cr &= \sum_{k=1}^{\8'} f \left( a + (k+1) \frac{b-a}{\8'} \right) - f \left( a + k \frac{b-a}{\8'} \right) \cr &= f \left( a + (\8'+1) \frac{b-a}{\8'} \right) - f \left( a + \frac{b-a}{\8'} \right) \cr &= f \left( a + (b - a) + 0' \right) - f \left( a + 0' \right) \cr &=' f(b) - f(a) \cr }$$

The equipoint approach allows us to easily discover that the natural logarithm can be expressed as a polynomial of order $0'$: $$ \ln y = \frac{y^{0'}-1}{0'}, $$ which shows that $\ds \int_1^t t^{-1} dt = \ln t$ is an instance of the general law $\ds \int_0^t t^n dt = \frac{t^{n+1}}{n+1}$ and not an exception.

The Dirac delta function $\delta(x)$ can be defined as the derivative of the Heaviside step function. It is a true function in equipoint analysis, but it is defined only in unfolded arithmetic, i.e. it is not the unfolding of any folded function.

−1 0 1 1 0′² 0′ 1/0′
Fig. 6:
Dirac delta function $\delta(x)$

Figure 6 shows the infinite value at $\delta(0)$. The microscope in this figure expands infinitely in the $x$ direction and contracts infinitely in the $y$ direction.

Unrestricted direct arithmetic in the derivative allows us to derive direct formulas for higher derivatives:

$$ \ds f^{(n)}(x) = \frac{\sum_{k=0}^n {{n}\choose{k}} (-1)^{n-k} f(x+0'k)}{0'^n}. $$

The indefinite integral can be derived from this formula as a negative order derivative: $$ \int f(x) dx = f^{(-1)}(x) = \sum_{k=1}^{\8'} f(x - 0'k) \; 0'. $$

Unrestricted direct arithmetic means that the derivative of any function is defined, including functions that have no conventional derivative. One example is the Dirac delta function, which as mentioned above can be defined as the derivative of the Heaviside step function. Another example is the Weierstrass function, which is a fractal, continuous everywhere but conventionally differentiable nowhere. The Weierstrass-like function $$ W(x) \equiv \sum_{n=0}^\8 \frac{\sin (2^n x)}{2^n} = \sin x + \frac{\sin 2x}2 + \frac{\sin 4x}4 + \dots $$ has the equipoint derivative $$ \frac{dW(x)}{dx} = \sum_{n=0}^\8 \cos (2^n x). $$

Complex functions which violate the Cauchy-Riemann equations are also equipoint differentiable. For example, for the function $$ M(x) \equiv 3 \Re z + 2 \Im z $$ the derivative at each point is a class of complex numbers which depends on the unit of differentiation $0'$: $$ \frac{\ds{}_{0'}\s2 d}{\ds{}_{0'}\s2 dz} M(x) = \frac{3 \cos \arg 0' + 2i \sin \arg 0'}{\sgn 0'}.$$

Equipoint analysis may improve the understanding of quantum renormalization. A very simplified example is to evaluate $$ \int_{-\8}^{\8} x^2\;dx, $$ which is conventionally evaluated through limits. In the equipoint approach, we we avoid limits and directly write $$ \frac1{\8'^3} \int_{-\8'}^{\8'} x^2\;dx = \frac23.$$

Divergent series

The third of the source documents on numeristics is Divergent series: A numeristic approach [CD]. This document describes an alternative approach to the theory of divergent series using numeristic principles. Key concepts and results include the following.

The conventional theory of divergent series was pioneered by Euler and given substantial expression by Hardy, whose posthumous work on the subject is considered a classic. Euler and Hardy each start out with the following result for $|a| > 1$: $$ \sum_{k=m}^\8 a^k = a^m + a^{m+1} + a^{m+2} + a^{m+3} + \dots = \frac{a^m}{1-a}. $$

The conventional theory as expressed by Hardy then uses methods of summation, an approach which has several weaknesses:

  1. An unworkable conception of weak equality.
  2. The failure of all methods, except one expressed by Euler, to account for the above result.
  3. A faulty understanding on the part of Hardy of Euler’s method, including a circular definition, and failure to realize this method as an extension of arithmetic.

Euler’s method is the principle that we do not reject an algebraic process simply because it deals with divergent series. If we find an algebraic process that is valid for a convergent case, then we assume that that process is also valid for the corresponding divergent case.

The numeristic theory of divergent series firmly justifies Euler’s method and not other methods of summation. The numeristic approach extends Euler’s method to yield the following two appraoches:

  1. Recursion, which is Euler’s method coupled with the understanding that most infinite series have at least two values, one finite and one infinite. For example, using recursion, we establish that $1 + 2 + 4 + 8 + \dots = \{-1, \8\}$.
  2. Equipoint summation, which uses equipoint analysis. Equipoint analysis allows each each number to be unfolded into an infinite space of unfolded numbers. Equipoint summation unfolds each term of an infinite series, which shows that the sum of a divergent series may depend on the mode of unfolding. For instance, $1 - 1 + 1 - 1 + \dots$ may have the value $\8$, $\frac12$, an arbitrary finite number, 1, or 0, depending on the mode of unfolding.

Other results include: $$\eqalign{ \sum_{k=-\8}^\8 a^k &= \dots + a^{-3} + a^{-2} + a^{-1} + a^0 + a^{1} + a^{2} + a^{3} + \dots = \left\{ 0, \8 \right\} \cr \sum_{k=0}^\8 e^{kix} &= 1 + e^{ix} + e^{2ix} + e^{3ix} + \dots = \left\{ \frac{1 + i\cot \frac{x}2}2, \8 \right\} \cr \int_0^\8 a^x dx &= \left\{ \frac{-1}{\ln a}, \8 \right\} \cr }$$

Repeating decimals

The fourth of the source documents on numeristics is Repeating decimals: A numerisitic approach [CR]. This document contains various theorems and proofs about repeating decimals, most of which are conventional, but also with some numeristic extensions. Key concepts and results include the following.

A repeating decimal is a convergent geometric series. Based on the results of [CD], a repeating decimal in the projectively extended real numbers is multivalued: $$\eqalign{ 0.\concat\;\ol{d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P} &= \sum_{K=1}^\8 (d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P) \cdot 10^{-PK} \cr &= \left\{ \frac R{10^P - 1}, \8 \right\}, \cr }$$ where

  • $d_n$ is a digit $0 \dots 9$.
  • $a \concat b$ denotes numeric concatenation, a number whose decimal representation is created by stringing together the decimal representations or symbols of $a$ and $b$. For example, if $a = 19$ and $b = 52$, then $a \concat b = 1952$, and $a \concat . \concat b = 19.52$.
  • $R = d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P$ is the repetend.
  • $P$ is the period.

For example, $$\eqalign{ 0.333 \dots = 0.\ol3 = \sum_{K=1}^\8 3 \cdot 10^{-K} &= \left\{ \frac13, \8 \right\} \cr 0.999 \dots = 0.\ol9 &= \{ 1, \8 \} \cr }$$

A left repeating decimal has an infinite number of repeating digits to the left of the decimal point. This type of decimal is a divergent geometric series, which is also multivalued: $$\eqalign{ \ol{d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P} &= \sum_{K=0}^\8 (d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P) \cdot 10^{PK} \cr &= \left\{ -\frac R{10^P - 1}, \8 \right\}, \cr }$$ and $$\eqalign{ \dots 333 = \ol3 = \sum_{K=0}^\8 3 \cdot 10^K &= \left\{ -\frac13, \8 \right\} \cr \dots 999 = \ol9 &= \{ -1, \8 \} \cr }$$

Right and left repeating decimals with the same repetend are negatives: $$\eqalign{ \ol{d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P}\;\concat.\concat\;\ol{d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P} &= \sum_{K=-\8}^\8 (d_1\concat d_2\concat d_3\concat\dots\concat d_P) \cdot 10^{-PK} \cr &= \{ 0, \8 \} \cr \ol3.\ol3 = \ol9.\ol9 &= \{ 0, \8 \} \cr }$$

When we allow infinite left decimals, every real number has an infinite number of representations.

Acknowledgment

The author wishes to thank the organizers, participants, and supporters of the Invincible America Assembly at Maharishi International University in Fairfield, Iowa for creating one of the best research environments in the world.

References
CD K. Carmody, Divergent series: A numeristic approach, 500K.
CE K. Carmody, Equipoint analysis: A numeristic approach to calculus, 600K.
CN K. Carmody, Numeristics: A number-based foundational theory of mathematics, 400K.
CR K. Carmody, Repeating decimals: A numerisitic approach, 300K.

This overview and the above four documents are available in printed form as a single volume Numeristic Mathematics: A Natural Approach to Calculating with Infinity  •  amazon.com/dp/B0F26BG4P2  •  Also available from these Amazon marketplaces: Canada, UK, Germany, France, Spain, Italy, Netherlands, Poland, Sweden, Australia, Japan  •  Printed book includes table of contents, full reference list, and indexes, which are not online.  •  Twelfth edition, 21 June 2025.